Hospital process orientation from an operations management. A final objective arises from bouckaert and halligans typology and especially. To identify a path forward, bouckaert and halligans performance management theoretical framework is employed to provide an additional layer of analysis. Paper presented at study group on productivity and quality in the public sector. In fact, the private sector idea of strategic management has become so powerful in the public sector that politicians and policy makers have begun to talk about the importance of the modern state being strategic and we may be witnessing the emergence of. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. The third idealized model described by bouckaert and halligan is a comprehensive and integrated performance management framework. Theoretical framework and research questions in a context of growing uncertainty, the ability of institutions to adapt themselves to new strategic challenges and. Performance management in the public sector routledge. Strategic management in the public sector paul joyce download. Characterization and definition of public performance. The chapter develops a performance management policy approach that includes several principles. Performance management in the public sector ebook by.
Also, contextual factors affect the effectiveness of performance management especially in public sector organisations where organisational goals are not explicitly stated, unlike the private sector. Accountability theory, based in the work of dubnickromzek, bovens, behn, bouckaert, halligan and pollitt, is discussed and related to different aspects of performance. Based on this analytical structure, the authors built a framework in which they discern. In times of rising expectations and decreasing resources for the public sector, performance management is high on the agenda. This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. The focus was on the analysis of the documents prepared by the italian lhos to highlight whether. A qualitative multilevel analysis of transformational leadership and perceived professional quality show all authors. International comparisons kindle edition by bouckaert, geert, halligan, john, halligan, john. The two countries in the authors case studies that seem to come closest to this approach are australia and canada. This paper seeks to extend the analysis of performance management regimes by bouckaert and halligan to other countries in order to contribute to the developing theory of forms and challenges in public sector performance management.
Performance management in the public sector takes as its point of departure a broad definition of performance to redefine major and basic mechanisms in public administration, both theoretically. Measuring performance based budgeting in flemish and italian. Pdf current state of public sector performance management in. Purpose this article seeks to assess how performance management in the public domain has evolved over the last several years both in terms of theory and practice in selected countries. This forms a logical sequence of collecting data, integration of data into the. Performance management in the public sector springerlink. Designmethodologyapproach the state of performance management and the context in which it. Integrative approach to effective performance management. The logics of performance management christopher pollitt, 20. Van dooren, bouckaert and halligan 2010 define the pas as a systematic collection of data that involves the observation and registration of the employees performance. Checking is refined by the foundation of suitable measurements to track framework execution for answering to administration. In light of the theoretical framework and the legislation mentioned above, the remaining part of the paper will present the results of an empirical investigation considering the initial years of the reform implementation 20112014.
This model seems to be favored by both academics and consultants. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click on download. Performance management in the public sector routledge masters in public management van dooren, wouter on. The book provides a framework through which models of performance management can be understood in terms of both their impact within a public sector organization, and the effects that have been seen in countries with contrasting administrational contexts. A framework for comparative analysis of performance management geert bouckaert and john halligan paper for presentation to study.
Tackling the key topics of reform and modernization, this important new book systematically examines performance in public management systems. Performance management in the public sector wouter van. Accompanying this trend is the increasing use of accounting and calculative practices such as performance management and strategic planning to. Increasingly, the value of the performance management systems themselves is under scrutiny, with more attention being paid to the effectiveness of performance management in practice. There have been many debates over the value of performance, measurement and its management, specifications of its components and their. Jan 22, 2014 this paper starts with a theoretical discussion on the relationship between performance and accountability in public organizations with a special focus on administrative reforms. Foucaults perspective of performance appraisal in public.
Application of the multiple governance framework hupe and hill 2006. First, policy making and implementation can be enriched by performance management mechanisms in a way that will improve government effectiveness and strengthen accountability and public responsibility in democracies. Mapping performance budgeting practices in local governments. Bouckaert and halligan 2008 not only discern between measurement, incorporation and use of performance information, they also distinguish several dimensions within each of these three components. According to bouckaert and halligan 2007, managing performance consists of measuring, incorporating and. Application of isbalanced scorecard in performance.
Performance management in the public sector, effective. Designmethodologyapproach drawing on bouckaert and halligan as a framework for analysing performance management in the. Managing performance in flemish local governments ku leuven. Increasingly, the value of the performance management systems themselves is under scrutiny, with more attention being paid to the effectiveness of performance management in. The concept of wicked problems has attracted increasing focus in policy research, but the implications for public organizations have received less attention. Strategic management in the public sector paul joyce. Bouckaert and halligan, 2008, halachmi and bouckaert, 1996. Pdf a framework for comparative analysis of performance.
These are summarized in a table and comparisons made to generate additional insights into the factors that influence the shape and speed of public management evolution. This research applied the balanced scorecard concept to audit performance of egovernment services at kenya revenue authority. Aug 16, 2017 given the prevalence of performance management in western policy administration, there is value in analyzing how, if it is to remain, performance management can be improved. The purpose of this article is to develop a new framework the lifecycle model for. Managing performance av geert bouckaert, john halligan ebok. An analysis was made on how kra developed performance measurement data. Drawing on the theoretical frameworks of bouckaert and halligan 2007 and jakobsen et al. Findings the paper finds that the bouckaert and halligan framework for analyzing public sector performance management is useful, albeit with some modifications. Strategic management is widely seen as essential to the public services, leading to better performance and better outcomes for the public.
Managing performance ebook by geert bouckaert 97814097265. We use the first form of the framework proposed by bouckaert and halligan to compare the two cases with respect to the measurement, integration and use of performance information. The two countries in the authors case studies that seem to come closest to this approach. Drawing on bouckaert and halligan as a framework for analysing performance management in the public sector. Largescale events, which are characterized by a dynamic complexity involving different national public administrations and institutional levels, require a special attention in selecting adequate project management and event management systems, and in designing and implementing multistakeholder management and engagement techniques. Mar 09, 2012 purpose this article seeks to assess how performance management in the public domain has evolved over the last several years both in terms of theory and practice in selected countries.
Group on productivity and quality in the public sector, conference of european group of public administration, universit bocconi, milan, 69 september 2006 abstract performance management lacks a coherent treatment that analyses its several dimensions as a working. Designmethodologyapproach drawing on bouckaert and halligan as a framework for analysing. Information society and library evaluation transitions in. Managing performance international comparisons critically examines the effects of performance management models in the public sector, and assesses their future evolution. A systematic study of the existing performance tools was carried out in establishing the basis for conceptualizing the information systems balanced scorecard.
Bouckaert and halligan 2008 can equally be transposed as dimensions of pb demeulenaere et al, 20. We find that both organizations have encountered benefits. This article analyses a variety of alternative logics, covering a range of different types of gaming, cheating and symbolic uses. Public management has become an area of focus in the developed as well as developing countries from the late eighties onwards.
A framework for comparative analysis of performance management geert bouckaert and john halligan paper for presentation to study group on productivity and quality in the public sector. The paper also aims to act as the editorial for the special issue of the journal. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. A metaevaluation model and frameworks 197020 the need for greater understanding of assessment practices and models highlights a deficit of an uptodate metaevaluation model, whilst articulating with new phases in information society is development. The authors wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, and john halligan are. Our recent book bouckaert and halligan 2007 has provided a framework for analysing the comparative experience that comprises ideal types of different ways of managing performance, official models for six countries and the operations of these systems in practice. Pdf performance management in the public sector researchgate.
Combining ideal types of performance and performance regimes. Fabric a framework for performance information substantiated. Purpose this paper seeks to extend the analysis of performance management regimes by bouckaert and halligan to other countries in order to contribute to the developing theory of forms and challenges in public sector performance management. Performance management 07 28483 dwl mpa 8 view online 150 items performance management in the public sector wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, john halligan, 2015, 2015 book essential essential book to this module. The findings will be of interest to scholars in public administration reform and performance management. To enable an adequate analysis of the evolution of performance. Increasingly, the value of the performance management systems themselves is under scrutiny, with more attention being paid to the effectiveness of performance management in p.
Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. However, this system has been widely criticized, not only due to the excessive attention given to the valuation of. The authors present this seminal subject in an informative and accessible manner, tackling some of the most important themes. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read performance management in the public sector.
The overall goal of performance management is to link the sequences of the traditional linear process of policymaking together in a cyclic and continuous process of innovation and learning that will ensure the development of better policy solutions van dooren, bouckaert, and halligan 2015, 21. Performance management in the public sector routledge masters in public management, by wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, john halligan. A framework for comparative analysis of performance management. Performance management in the public sector 2nd edition. Pdf on the road to performance governance in the public. Professional quality is understood as input when the professionals perceive the availability of certain. Fee download performance management in the public sector routledge masters in public management, by wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, john halligan. Pdf on the road to performance governance in the public domain. Van dooren, bouckaert and halligan 2010 define the pas as a systematic collection of data that involves the observation and registration of the employees. This paper starts with a theoretical discussion on the relationship between performance and accountability in public organizations with a special focus on administrative reforms. To identify a path forward, bouckaert and halligan s performance management theoretical framework is employed to provide an additional layer of analysis. In contrast, the way performance is looked at from a public management perspective, the point of departure is a certain scale of action locus, that is to say a single public organization, public manager or individual. Sage reference performance and performance management. Performance has become a defining feature of modern government.
According to bouckaert and halligan 2008, this framework consists of three steps, namely measurement, incorporation and use of performance information. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. It is an important book for all students and researchers with an interest in management, public administration and public policy. Mar 09, 2012 these are summarized in a table and comparisons made to generate additional insights into the factors that influence the shape and speed of public management evolution. Information society and library evaluation transitions in portugal. The study also identified the core questions that need further investigation. Measuring performance based budgeting in flemish and. Performance management in the public sector routledge masters in public management.
The first level is macro, where a performance framework would reach across an entire. Performance management in the public sector routledge masters. Jul 14, 2015 application of isbalanced scorecard in performance measurement of egovernment services in kenya. Wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, john halligan abstract. Edition 2 ebook written by wouter van dooren, geert bouckaert, john halligan. Figure 1 visualizes how pb fits in with this broader framework of managing performance. The ones marked may be different from the article in the profile. Originalityvalue the countries studied provide a rare insight into lesserknown performance management regimes and the use of the bouckaert and halligan framework allows for comparisons to earlier and future research. Since its publication in 2000, public management reform has established itself as the standard text in the field, presenting a comparative analysis of recent changes in public management and public administration in a range of countries in europe, north america, and australasia. A framework for comparative analysis of performance. If transparency in performance measurement becomes mandatory.
Performance and accountabilitya theoretical discussion and. A framework has been developed to analyse managing performance. Feb 19, 2015 performance management in the public sector. On the road to performance governance in the public domain.
Achieving high quality through transformational leadership. Given the prevalence of performance management in western policy administration, there is value in analyzing how, if it is to remain, performance management can be improved. The lifecycle approach to performance management citeseerx. After explaining the adaptations made to the original oecd survey and building on the framework of managing performance of bouckaert and halligan 2008, this paper elaborates on the results from eight interviews performed in both flemish and italian municipalities. Performance and accountabilitya theoretical discussion.
399 1148 446 415 256 1068 1378 1395 337 671 671 1458 1483 576 1408 1562 1441 924 1153 1461 631 982 449 760 90 784 379 193 1067 1600 2 405 1621 1219 457 386 305 679 818 215 1145 1015 398 93 560 310